Skip to main content
Spread the love

Summer time screams Smores and this gelato is jam packed with delicious smore flavors plus a little extra with rich and creamy nutella. This delicious homemade S’mores Nutella Gelato is perfect for warm Summer nights.  Nutella S'more Gelato

I am making all your smore ice cream dreams come true with this recipe. It technically isn’t ice cream, it’s gelato. 

I get asked a lot “what is the difference between gelato and ice cream”?  I am going to answer all your questions about gelato and give you a pretty tasty smores gelato with nutella recipe to try out for yourself. But first let’s learn how gelato came to be. 

*This information is from my pastry class I took during culinary school in Florence, Italy.

History of gelato:

The oldest form of ice cream is the sorbetto.  Back in ancient times in Asia and the Middle East people would mix fruit juices with snow.  The earliest milk based ice cream dates back to China about 3000 BC when a milk and rice mixture was frozen by packing it into snow. 

There is some controversy with modern day gelatos exact inventor but most people would agree it was credited to Bernardo Buontalenti, a native of Florence, who delighted the court of Catherina dei Medici with his creation. The Italian word for ice cream is gelato. But don’t get too confused because there is a different. 

Gelato was regularly served at the Medici court in Florence at the time that Catherine De Medici married the King of France in 1533.  She had an amazing array of gelato chefs, Buontalenti being one of them.   She has said to be the one to introduced France to the decadent treat. 

Gelato now a days:

Italians take pride in making their gelato with high quality ingredients that provide energy to fuel them.  In Italy gelato is considered a healthy snack. They eat it in moderation and don’t add any artificial flavors and preservatives.  They literally eat it every day.  And I did too when I lived there, okay maybe I ate it two times a day. The smores gelato recipe is a spin on two of my favorite gelato flavors in Italy; nutella and cookie. 


infographic showing the differences between ice cream and gelato

The differences between gelato and ice cream:

There are a few distinct differences between gelato and ice cream.  Gelato is made with less cream, less eggs (sometimes no egg) and is served at a little higher temperature than American made ice cream.  It is also supposed to be churned slower to incorporate less air which gives it a very smooth, velvety texture (this is called overrun). 

What is overrun:

Overrun is the amount or volume of ice cream obtained after churning that is in excess of the volume of the base.  It is actually the amount of air incorporated into the mix during the freezing and churning process.  A 100% overrun would describe a custard that has doubled in volume during freezing.  This is the maximum overrun allowed by the FDA.  While some overrun is necessary for a smooth and light texture, too much will give the ice cream an airiness and a less intense flavor.  A dense ice cream, such as the Italian gelato has a lower percentage of overrun than an American made ice cream thus creating a texture that yields a high intensity of flavor. 

Overrun is determined by:

*The Freezing Equipment

*The length of time the ice cream spends in the ice cream freezer.  It should be removed as son as it is frozen. 

*The amount of custard in relation to the freezer size.  For maximum overrun, the freezer should be filled only halfway.  

*The ingredients in the mixture that affect its ability to increase, for example eggs. 

In conclusion, whether you are a fan of gelato or you prefer American made ice cream, making it is as easy as making ice cream. 


How do you store gelato at home?

I store my gelato in plastic soup containers or freezer containers.  You can also buy these ice cream containers as well.  -You want to store the gelato in your freezer and make sure it is in the range of 0-10 degrees F. 

How long does gelato last?

Most people will tell you if you make gelato at home that it can be stored for months.  Some people say up to 6 months, but lets face it it just isn’t as good the longer it is frozen.  I recommend eating it straight from the bowl (haha) but if you have to freeze it I recommend eating it within a couple of weeks. I promise though it won’t last that long!

Why is my gelato icy?

Ice creams have higher fat contents which help them to freeze better and be very thick and creamy.  Gelato has a higher proportion of milk (higher water content) which can cause the gelato to become icy.  I recommend making gelato and eating it as soon as possible.  It is also meant to be served at a slightly higher temperature so if it is very icy place it in the fridge for 10-20 minutes before serving to raise the temperature.

 Does gelato contain raw egg?

No, most gelato do not contain any eggs at all, but some recipes do call for egg yolks.  The one below does have egg yolks.  The process includes heating the egg yolk, but if you are pregnant or have dietary restrictions I would use a recipe that does not contain any eggs at all.  If you are looking for an egg free option check out this Ice Cream In A Bag. 

Do you have any other ice cream or gelato recipes?

Yes! You can check out the recipe links below. –Ice Cream In A BagDairy Free Mint Oreo Ice Cream. 

How to make Smores Gelato:

Nutella S'more Gelato from More Momma
Yield: 6 servings

Smores Gelato with Nutella

Easy Nutella S'more Gelato is the perfect dessert for any Summer get together.


  • 2 Cups Milk
  • 1 Cup Granulated Sugar
  • 3/4 Cup Cream
  • 2 Egg Yolks (optional)
  • 1 Teaspoon Vanilla Bean Paste
  • 1/4 Cup Nutella
  • 2 Graham Crackers


  1. In a small saucepan over medium low heat warm 1/2 of the milk. 
  2. In a mixing bowl cream together the egg yolk and sugar.  
  3. Stream in the warm milk to the egg yolks (constantly whisking) and combine. 
  4. Add the vanilla bean paste and cream and whisk to combine. 
  5. Run the mixture through a fine mesh strainer to strain out any curdled egg pieces (this is a very important step for texture). 
  6. Cover the mixture with saran wrap (touching the liquid) to prevent a film from forming. Place in the fridge for 1 hour or until the mixture is very cold. 
  7. Place your cold gelato base into your ice cream maker (make sure it has been frozen for at least 24 hours). Turn on the machine and let churn for 15-20 minutes or until it becomes frozen. 
  8. Turn the machine off and fold in the Nutella and graham crackers.*You will need to add the Nutella in spoonfuls since it will tend to seize up when it hits the cold gelato. 
  9. Place in the freezer for 10-20 minutes to set.


    I highly recommend enjoying this gelato immediately. If you freeze for long periods of time leave out at room temperature for 10 minutes for desired texture.

    Nutrition Information:



    Serving Size:


    Amount Per Serving: Calories: 365Total Fat: 17gSaturated Fat: 11gTrans Fat: 0gUnsaturated Fat: 5gCholesterol: 102mgSodium: 80mgCarbohydrates: 48gFiber: 1gSugar: 41gProtein: 5g


    Spread the love
    Skip to Recipe